The Battle of Gel Liners: Etude House Drawing Show Vs. Maybelline Lasting Drama Gel Liner

Hello Everyone!! This will be my very first Vs blogpost and I'm really excited about it :) 

 Enough with the Chitchat!

On the Left Corner: Maybelline Lasting Drama Gel Liner (LD)

and on the Right Corner: Etude House Drawing Show Gel Liner (DS)

the DS really catches everyone's attention  because of the cutest packaging

LD has 2.8g while DS has 3.5g on the bottle

LD's brush is more slender and half longer than the DS's

 QUICK TIP!:

if you want your drawing show brush be a little longer insert the cap on its butt :)

just push it in

the LD has smaller packaging than the DS

when the cap is attached it can be used as an extended handle 

the DS dries a little faster than the LD

ooops, the LD transferred because its not that dry after 15 seconds

LD has a semi- matte finish while the DS  has matte finish

TEST TIME!!

WATERPROOFINESS:

soaked under water for 20 seconds

after rubbing once

SMUDGEPROOFINESS:

rubbed 4x
the LD stayed while the DS didn't quite stay well

after rubbing 15x
the DS is merely visible

what it looks on the eyes left eye is the LD and on the right eye is the DS

the LD transferred on the outer corner of my eyes..

and so as the DS but it didn't transferred as much as the LD

TRANSFERPROOFINESS:

LD

it transferred a little

DS

it transferred alot! but cannot merely see because it doesn't scatter its color

OVERALL RATING:  

 Maybelline Lasting Drama Gel Liner (LD)                                           Etude House Drawing Show (DS)

                                                                   PACKAGING                         Winner (travel safe)

Winner(Thinner brush-precise line)                     BRUSH

                                                                       TEXTURE              Winner (applies smoother dries quickier)

  cost 449 2.8g (160/g)                               AFFORDABILITY                cost 498 3.5g (142/ g)

                      Winner                                   WATERPROOF

                                                                  SMUDGEPROOF          Winner (doesn't scatter color )

                                                                  TRANSFERPROOF       Winner (doesn't transfer that much)

  Winner! (stays alot longer)                       LASTING POWER          

OVERALL WINNER: 

ETUDE HOUSE DRAWING SHOW

-it did not scatter its color that's what I love about it! Even though the LD stays a lot longer but it just scatter its color therefore its just creating panda eyes. I love the packaging because its on a plastic bottle that's very lightweight and cannot be easily broken even if dropped because I'm really clumsy haha! It glides smoother than the LD.